diff --git a/lua/neogit/lib/util.lua b/lua/neogit/lib/util.lua
index 46c9942f6..2a763e23d 100644
--- a/lua/neogit/lib/util.lua
+++ b/lua/neogit/lib/util.lua
@@ -623,4 +623,15 @@ function M.try(fn, ...)
   end
 end
 
+---@param str string
+---@param prefix string
+---@return string
+function M.remove_prefix(str, prefix)
+  if str:sub(1, #prefix) == prefix then
+    return str:sub(#prefix + 1)
+  else
+    return str
+  end
+end
+
 return M
diff --git a/lua/neogit/popups/push/actions.lua b/lua/neogit/popups/push/actions.lua
index 26fd6df56..4c50aa343 100644
--- a/lua/neogit/popups/push/actions.lua
+++ b/lua/neogit/popups/push/actions.lua
@@ -119,17 +119,19 @@ function M.push_other(popup)
   end
 
   local destinations = git.refs.list_remote_branches()
-  for _, remote in ipairs(git.remote.list()) do
-    table.insert(destinations, 1, remote .. "/" .. source)
-  end
 
   local destination = FuzzyFinderBuffer.new(util.deduplicate(destinations))
     :open_async { prompt_prefix = "push " .. source .. " to" }
+
   if not destination then
     return
   end
 
   local remote, _ = git.branch.parse_remote_branch(destination)
+
+  -- destination is <remote>/branch-name, need to remove the remote prefix
+  destination = util.remove_prefix(destination, remote .. "/")
+
   push_to(popup:get_arguments(), remote, source .. ":" .. destination)
 end